The rules like introduction and elimination are not to allow you writing anything you want, but to help you using or creating a formula with a concrete operator.
That's why, if you have , you can't say ``now I do negation
introduction and get
, which is what I needed''.
There are some requisites for each rule, and if you don't fulfill
them, you can't apply that rule.
For instance: the rule implication elimination doesn't allow to use the formulas in the first line this way:
To be able to do this, we would need to be sure that is always
true; then we could apply the rule, correctly writing the line numbers.
Daniel Clemente Laboreo 2005-05-17